Welcome to The Old Feed Mill, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Mazomanie, Wisconsin. Located at 114 Cramer St, this historic mill has been transformed into a dining haven that marries rustic charm with gourmet elegance. From the moment you step inside, the inviting atmosphere whispers tales of old-world charm, enhanced by modern decor and friendly service. With a phone number of +1 608-795-4909, making a reservation is just a call away, especially if you plan to dine after a show at the nearby American Players Theatre.

The menu at The Old Feed Mill is a carefully curated selection of dishes that celebrate seasonal ingredients and classic comfort food. One standout dish is the Mushroom Strudel, featuring portabella and button mushrooms, caramelized onions, and roasted red peppers, all beautifully encased in flaky phyllo dough and drizzled with a rich porcini mushroom béchamel. At just US$13.00, this dish not only satisfies the palate but also brings an artistic touch to the table. Another crowd-pleasing option is the Miller's Meat Loaf, a homemade Italian classic that's hearty and satisfying.

Moving beyond the entrees, the selection of salads is equally impressive. The Summer Salad, for instance, combines mixed greens, fresh strawberries, blue cheese, and crunchy pecans for a delightful medley of flavors at US$11.00. Meanwhile, the Classic Caesar is a timeless favorite, ensuring that even the simplest of dishes shines with quality ingredients and careful preparation.

Satisfy your cravings further with one of their hearty sandwiches. The Old Mill Burger is a testament to their focus on simplicity and quality, featuring a juicy 1/3 lb. charbroiled patty served on a kaiser roll, along with fresh toppings—all for just US$9.00. The classic Reuben, brimming with hot, shaved corned beef and Swiss cheese, is a must-try for sandwich lovers.

Customer experiences echo the heartwarming ambiance of The Old Feed Mill. Patrons share stories of enjoying a cozy dinner while appreciating the attentive service. Reviewers have praised the intimate, romantic setting, making it a perfect spot for date nights or special occasions. With both indoor and outdoor dining options, every visit offers a unique dining experience tailored to your mood and preference.

Perhaps what makes The Old Feed Mill truly special is not just the delectable food but the warmth of the staff. As one happy customer remarked, even on a cold January night, the service was exceptional, adding a personal touch that elevates the entire dining experience. The combination of excellent food and hospitable service makes every meal here memorable.

In summary, The Old Feed Mill excels in offering a blend of rustic charm and culinary creativity, providing a comforting escape from the everyday hustle. Whether you’re savoring the exquisite Mushroom Strudel or indulging in the comforting Miller's Meat Loaf, each dish is a testament to their commitment to quality. For an unforgettable dining experience, don’t miss the opportunity to explore the magic of The Old Feed Mill.